Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

'18 secondary: Better than '16?

TTJ
TTJ Member Posts: 4,827
SS McINTOSH McKinney
FS RAPP Gilchrist
NICKEL JOYNER Molden
CB MILLER Taylor
CB MURPHY Gordon


«1

Comments

  • doogie
    doogie Member Posts: 15,072
    I just hope they stay injury-free the rest of the way
  • AEB
    AEB Member Posts: 2,994
    TTJ said:

    I’m surprised I’m surprised how much Murphy/Miller underappreciation is going on in this thread.

    Love em. Not enough reps due to injuries to claim equivalence
  • chuck
    chuck Member, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 11,679 Swaye's Wigwam
    TTJ said:

    I’m surprised I’m surprised how much Murphy/Miller underappreciation is going on in this thread.

    Premature is all. Murphy has shown he's a big play guy but not that he's a shutdown one on one cover corner that can stay consistent over a whole season. Miller had a bit of a rough start this year but pulled it together. I think they're both good but haven't reached Jones-King stature yet and it's hard to predict it based on the little we've seen.

    So...maybe?
  • NeGgaPlEaSe
    NeGgaPlEaSe Member Posts: 5,763
    edited December 2017
    Doogles said:

    Unless Rapp goes full Budda, no.

    King was a freak, SMFJ was the best DB on the field, Budda was special, and Rapp was a TF.

    Fully expect Rapp to be better than Budda to be honest. That’s my opinion so fuck off (even though he underperformed this year)
    And none those guys from 2016 were as highly touted coming out of high school as Murphy Joyner, Gilchrist so let’s hope Lake is earning his pay. Murphy is a stud, he’s a first round pick.
    Now if you add Marcus Black Panther Peters to that 2016 team, I will say fuck no, no how no way ever. That would have gone down as the best secondary in UW history.
  • AtomicDawg
    AtomicDawg Member Posts: 7,331

    Doogles said:

    Unless Rapp goes full Budda, no.

    King was a freak, SMFJ was the best DB on the field, Budda was special, and Rapp was a TF.

    Fully expect Rapp to be better than Budda to be honest. That’s my opinion so fuck off (even though he underperformed this year)
    And none those guys from 2016 were as highly touted coming out of high school as Murphy Joyner, Gilchrist so let’s hope Lake is earning his pay. Murphy is a stud, he’s a first round pick.
    Now if you add Marcus Black Panther Peters to that 2016 team, I will say fuck no, no how no way ever. That would have gone down as the best secondary in UW history.
    Rapp and Budda are different players but it's hard to be more effective than a 1st team all American. Budda was ridiculous that year.
  • Gilbystaint
    Gilbystaint Member Posts: 1,061

    Doogles said:

    Unless Rapp goes full Budda, no.

    King was a freak, SMFJ was the best DB on the field, Budda was special, and Rapp was a TF.

    Fully expect Rapp to be better than Budda to be honest. That’s my opinion so fuck off (even though he underperformed this year)
    And none those guys from 2016 were as highly touted coming out of high school as Murphy Joyner, Gilchrist so let’s hope Lake is earning his pay. Murphy is a stud, he’s a first round pick.
    Now if you add Marcus Black Panther Peters to that 2016 team, I will say fuck no, no how no way ever. That would have gone down as the best secondary in UW history.
    Rapp and Budda are different players but it's hard to be more effective than a 1st team all American. Budda was ridiculous that year.
    Agree with all this. Budda was a one man wrecking crew back there by the end of last year and is continuing to shine at the next level. I think Mr. Murphy Jr. is going to emerge the same way.
  • Pitchfork51
    Pitchfork51 Member Posts: 27,662
    Swaye said:

    It's all a slow downward spiral from 2016 you shitdicks.

    Ever since @jhfstyle24 shit all over his own dick we are all getting painted with this broad brush of hate.
    I have a lot of hate in my life
  • puppylove_sugarsteel
    puppylove_sugarsteel Member Posts: 9,133
    edited December 2017
    TTJ said:

    SS McINTOSH McKinney
    FS RAPP Gilchrist
    NICKEL JOYNER Molden
    CB MILLER Taylor
    CB MURPHY Gordon


    Yup...and a really fucking good true freshman is coming in in Hampton. This is higher discussion board material
  • FireCohen
    FireCohen Member Posts: 21,823
    Miller was getting to that level before he got hurt.
  • Gladstone
    Gladstone Member Posts: 16,419

    Doogles said:

    Unless Rapp goes full Budda, no.

    King was a freak, SMFJ was the best DB on the field, Budda was special, and Rapp was a TF.

    Fully expect Rapp to be better than Budda to be honest. That’s my opinion so fuck off (even though he underperformed this year)
    And none those guys from 2016 were as highly touted coming out of high school as Murphy Joyner, Gilchrist so let’s hope Lake is earning his pay. Murphy is a stud, he’s a first round pick.
    Now if you add Marcus Black Panther Peters to that 2016 team, I will say fuck no, no how no way ever. That would have gone down as the best secondary in UW history.
    Rapp underperformed this year? Explain.
  • FireCohen
    FireCohen Member Posts: 21,823
    Gladstone said:

    Doogles said:

    Unless Rapp goes full Budda, no.

    King was a freak, SMFJ was the best DB on the field, Budda was special, and Rapp was a TF.

    Fully expect Rapp to be better than Budda to be honest. That’s my opinion so fuck off (even though he underperformed this year)
    And none those guys from 2016 were as highly touted coming out of high school as Murphy Joyner, Gilchrist so let’s hope Lake is earning his pay. Murphy is a stud, he’s a first round pick.
    Now if you add Marcus Black Panther Peters to that 2016 team, I will say fuck no, no how no way ever. That would have gone down as the best secondary in UW history.
    Rapp underperformed this year? Explain.
    pac-12 stayed the fuck away from him this whole season. He made plays when he was targeted.
  • dnc
    dnc Member Posts: 56,839
    Doogles said:

    Unless Rapp goes full Budda, no.

    King was a freak, SMFJ was the best DB on the field, Budda was special, and Rapp was a TF.

    I think it's possible and I BRBYO all over the 16 secondary. Sr JoJo >>>> So JoJo. Jr Rapp >>>> Fr Rapp. So there's 2/5 that 2018 already has. Murphy has the highest upside of any of them IMO and could match Sr Sidney, and I think Miller could be right there with King. Advantage 2016 but not huge IMO.

    So it comes down to Budda vs Joyner. Obviously Budda is better but Joyner is really good.

    I think the smart money would be on 18 not catching 16, but it's within the realistic realm for 2018 to be better. That's a damn good secondary. The big thing is they need to be healthy.
  • Gwad
    Gwad Member Posts: 2,855
    No..... 18 secondary has not played.
  • TierbsHsotBoobs
    TierbsHsotBoobs Member Posts: 39,680
    Gwad said:

    No..... 18 secondary has not played.

    Doogs love hypotheticals though.
  • TTJ
    TTJ Member Posts: 4,827
    TTJ said:

    SS McINTOSH McKinney
    FS RAPP Gilchrist
    NICKEL JOYNER Molden
    CB MILLER Taylor
    CB MURPHY Gordon


    Bumped to note who’s not in the 2-deeps.
  • whatshouldicareabout
    whatshouldicareabout Member Posts: 12,991
    The 2018 secondary hasn't allowed a completion or any passing yards.
  • TierbsHsotBoobs
    TierbsHsotBoobs Member Posts: 39,680

    The 2018 secondary hasn't allowed a completion or any passing yards.

    I already hate it though