Who could be 5 stars in our class?
Comments
-
Ur mom says he has itDoogles said:People bash Sirmon on this board, I have no clue if he has "it" or not, but he makes a throw on his Hudl highlight rolling left against his body that is NFL caliber. It's fucking amazing, that is some 5 star shit.
-
You already are a full on doog. HTHBallzDeep said:Draco is good and reminds me of Trent Murphy who played for Stanford and was drafted in the second round. I'd have to go full on doog to believe Bynum will be a JJ Watt or Joey Bosa kind of guy and be a first rounder.
-
Confirmation bias is fun.BallzDeep said:
Well I guess it's a good thing Petersen is our coach then because he makes me look good in terms of my talent evaluations.Sources said:
You already are a full on doog. HTHBallzDeep said:Draco is good and reminds me of Trent Murphy who played for Stanford and was drafted in the second round. I'd have to go full on doog to believe Bynum will be a JJ Watt or Joey Bosa kind of guy and be a first rounder.
-
I like Draco I just don’t see that fast twitch that bosa and watt haveBallzDeep said:Draco is good and reminds me of Trent Murphy who played for Stanford and was drafted in the second round. I'd have to go full on doog to believe Bynum will be a JJ Watt or Joey Bosa kind of guy and be a first rounder.
-
yesrustysavage said:
Why do u go to doogpound and regurgitate stuff u have picked up here? I mean I know why u do it, but damn do u have no pride?jhfstyle24 said:
No love for Drace Bynum around hereRhythmicSlappingDawg said:
Hampton, Mele, Curne, Yankoff, Sirmon, Ale, Spkier, Kaho, Osborne, and Culp.DodgyBloke said:
Exactly what I meant by this post. By physical traits are some under rated?BallzDeep said:
Wasn't talking about rankings done by retards. Was talking about who I think has the physical potential and ability to be a first round pick. If were just talking rankings then yeah it's obviously some of the guys currently rated as 4-stars.RhythmicSlappingDawg said:
LBer Sirmon, Hampton, and Curne have no shot at being 5 stars.BallzDeep said:Osborne, Curne, Hampton, Yankoff, Sirmon, Sirmon, Kaho.
-
Doog thread of the year
-
This thread had bovine AIDS from the start. Good job guys, you brought back Rinderpest from extinction.
-
Togiai
-
I think this thread killed @SpiritHorseWilburHooksHands said:Doog thread of the year
-
If you drop 3 hits and stare into the sun for an hour you can bring him back.Swaye said: -
Challenge accepted.WilburHooksHands said:
If you drop 3 hits and stare into the sun for an hour you can bring him back.Swaye said:
-
Spider, Kano, Center, Servon, Yankov.
-
DDY scale I got from a guy who used to eval film for Don James.
He used to say from film alone you can tell football stuff not mental stuff, so he divided things into 3 categories for Don based on football skills and physical ability:
DDY1: Serious athletic/football flaws. Unlikely to become all conference.
Examples: Nik Little, Jordan Chin. Lots of Ty recruits.
DDY2: Tier of recruits where coaching is really going to matter most. They have a chance to be good, but are not elite physically AND elite football wise. One or the other or some combo of decent at both.
Example: Jake Browning, DJ Beavers.
I think of a “high 2” as someone who has elite physical ability and has shown flashes of elite football skills (or the reverse). Ultimately still a 2 because you don’t feel certain.
Example type I: Alex Cook
Example type II: Tevis Bartlett
Again the reason saying these guys are still “tier 2” is useful is because it’s meant to denote that they don’t have the whole thing together yet.
DDY3: Elite physical ability and elite football ability. Jump out on tape. Have something really special that separates them from other recruits.
Example: Taylor Rapp, Budda.
—again, most of this is predicated on the fact that I can’t know mental makeup and work habits from “tape triage”. Just kind of separate kids into “nah, has a chance and GET THIS KID.”
It’s a bit different than the star system in that it was really invented to place guys into tiers rather than “rankings”. Like I have no limit on numbers.
Guys like Osborne may not end up 5-stars, but he’s in the same physical tier as Amon-Ra St Brown. -
There should be a 4th tier for kids who have the entire package AND one of the coolest names ever. Example: Amon-Ra St. Brown. He's the fucking Sun God for tittie fucking sakes.
