So the Ninth Circuit held today, by a 2-1 vote. I tentatively think the majority got it right as a matter of First Amendment law and statutory interpretation, though I think such statutes ought to be written to include some privacy exceptions as to gender identity and not just sex.
I agree completely. I also think the Plaintiffs had far better arguments for challenging the agency, but their activist law firm wants to give the SCOTUS a First Amendment avenue to upend established principles yet again. 5-4? That would be my guess. I wouldn't bet the ranch on the outcome.
BidenBros don't know what sex they are. Strange situations arise when we have so few mental hospital facilities. MMHGA! Make Mental Hospitals Great Again! Lock them up until they can figure it out. They shouldn't be allowed near children ever.
@HHusky I cannot believe your side hasn’t yet learned that it’s shit like this that loses you elections.
Getting you tards to become the party of high taxes, endless foreign wars, open boarders and chicks with dicks is maybe the greatest political maneuver the GOP has ever pulled off.
Keep defending it. I beg of you. Make AOC the face of your party. I fucking BEG you.
You seem to be confused about who and what I defended. Hint: it wasn’t the state agency. But Courts are only supposed to decide the questions they have jurisdiction to decide and that they have been asked to decide. Like Gasbag’s favorite Constitutional lawyer, I think the Court got the correct answer to the question it was asked.
You girls really need some remedial civics instruction.
Comments
It’s obvious that H wants to be the guy in the locker room with the little girls.
"We definitely need more emotional rhetoric injected into Constitutional interpretation," Derek added.
I agree with H, I think Seattle should enforce the ruling.
you really wouldn’t like it if courts actually operated like that.
red herring
So the Ninth Circuit held today, by a 2-1 vote. I tentatively think the majority got it right as a matter of First Amendment law and statutory interpretation, though I think such statutes ought to be written to include some privacy exceptions as to gender identity and not just sex.
Eugene Volokh | 5.29.2025 2:41 PM
I agree completely. I also think the Plaintiffs had far better arguments for challenging the agency, but their activist law firm wants to give the SCOTUS a First Amendment avenue to upend established principles yet again. 5-4? That would be my guess. I wouldn't bet the ranch on the outcome.
Yeah bullshit
keep the dudes out of girls restroom and sports
Go strain at a different gnat
Then fuck off
Race reminds us that the stupids still think the question being answered was whether the Court prefers male freaks hang out nude in the spa.
BidenBros don't know what sex they are. Strange situations arise when we have so few mental hospital facilities. MMHGA! Make Mental Hospitals Great Again! Lock them up until they can figure it out. They shouldn't be allowed near children ever.
Sure
One of the great legal mysteries of our time
There are two genders Alice. Stay out of the girls room
Riiigghhht.
I mean really, what does Eugene Volokh know about the Constitution anyway?
Stay out of the girls room freak
@HHusky I cannot believe your side hasn’t yet learned that it’s shit like this that loses you elections.
Getting you tards to become the party of high taxes, endless foreign wars, open boarders and chicks with dicks is maybe the greatest political maneuver the GOP has ever pulled off.
Keep defending it. I beg of you. Make AOC the face of your party. I fucking BEG you.
You seem to be confused about who and what I defended. Hint: it wasn’t the state agency. But Courts are only supposed to decide the questions they have jurisdiction to decide and that they have been asked to decide. Like Gasbag’s favorite Constitutional lawyer, I think the Court got the correct answer to the question it was asked.
You girls really need some remedial civics instruction.
Riiight
Just keep doing what you’re doing. 👍
”I’m still out of ammunition!”, Race exclaimed.
Likable, but so so simple.
Article could also be titled “Korean spa prepares to close”
he hasn't had ammunition since his balls shriveled up about 50 years ago.