Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Options
On the 159th anniversary of popping a cap in Booth's ass - The Unions Greatest Civil War Victory
YellowSnow
Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 34,005
On the 159th anniversary of popping a cap in Booth's ass - The Unions Greatest Civil War Victory 13 votes
Shilo - 1862
7%
1 vote
Atlanta & Sherman's March to the Sea - 1864
23%
3 votes
Vicksburg - 1863
30%
4 votes
Gettysburg - 1863
7%
1 vote
Antietam - 1862
7%
1 vote
Overland Campaign (i.e., Grant committed to running the damn ball) - 1864
15%
2 votes
Chattanooga Campaign (Missionary Position Ridge) - 1864
0%
Mobile Bay (Damn the torpedoes!) - 1864
0%
F.O. Row Peter Puffer, you left off...
7%
1 vote
Comments
Back in sync
In my mind, Gettysburg has always been a bit overrated as an American victory. Yes, a loss their would have been catastrophic, but because Meade was such a pussy and let Lee escape, it didn't have much an impact on the overall strategic picture the way Vicksburg did. Gettysburg was just a big bloody mess with a massive home field advantage.
Vicksburg was going balls deep into enemy territory and ripping their guts out. And it got Grant on Lincoln's radar like never before, which is how the war was ultimately won.
Thud.
Don't any of you millennial douche canoes go to any Civil War battlefields ( @whlinder ) or have miniature reenactments?
Sad how far America has fallen.
Like we say, no.
It's OK. I've never been to a Civil War battlefield either.
Would like to see Gettysburg someday.
Millennial?
Ah hell naw
I went to Gettysburg like 3 weeks ago.
I'm hearing that Vantage will be the site of the 2nd Civil War.
If I grew up in the South I think I'd care more about the Civil War. I'm much more into the history of WW1 and WW2 when men were men and America knew how to fuck shit up to win a war.
He knew how to kick ass and burn any evidence. Hamas should hire him - well someone like him being he dead.
There’s a civil war battlefield in a place called Perryville or some shit like that. It’s a state park/memorial now and about an hour from Lexington.
I was going out that way and left early so I could stop and see the place. Fucking hate to the park was closed at 1pm on a Friday. That’s the closest I’ve ever been to a civil war battlefield unless you count some hiking in Chattanooga.
Civil war stuff is everywhere in this part of the country. Beyond just the battlefields, the names of everything are from that era. Now with the moves to change the names of things which were named for the losing side it can be utterly confusing to navigate certain areas I spent a lot of time in back in the day.
Part of this is due to living as an adult in the suburban bubble where everything was built new in the past 25 years vs growing up closer in to DC where the original names for things were set much further in the past.
Lee Highway. Jefferson-Davis Highway. Lee High School. Mosby Highway. Lee Jackson highway. There are a bunch more and they’ve all been changed now. I never even realized how ingrained it was in the area until names started to be changed.
I’ve been to Gettysburg, Antietam, Bull Run, some battlefield near Fredericksburg VA, Appomattox courthouse and a couple of memorials in Fredericksburg and Richmond. I should focus more on the Civil war and get my ancestor’s diaries transcribed. But I find WW2 way more interesting. I guess due to the global nature of it and the recency.
One thing I’ve noticed when I look at American military history books is that there’s a ton of Civil War, WWII, and Vietnam material but not nearly as much Revolution or WWI material.
World War 1 was not all that popular in America. Its the cause of sedition laws and other laws to stop dissent
It was also in the 4th quarter when the US squad showed up
A really stupid brutal and pointless war
We’re good at those kind of wars.
Arguably, the most pointless and stupid war in history. I've come around to the school of thought which considers WW1 and WW2 basically the same war, just with a 20 year half time.
You're right though @CFetters_Nacho_Lover there's not enough WW1 literature out there. Max Hasting's 1914 is recommended, of course. WW1 created all the isms of the 20th and so many of the conflicts we see today. The Jew - Arab fight really started to get its reads down as a result of WW1 and @Lawrence_of_a_Labia taking it to the Ottomans. It's too bad today's yoots on college campuses (TITTT) are so profoundly ignorant of the history of the Middle East.
At one of our Hardcore Husky get togethers last year we did a reenactment of the Grenada invasion
I get why my history pods think WW2 is more interesting than the US Civil War- i.e., the scale, the crazy dictators, the weaponry, etc.
What personally find move interesting about the Civil War is that it was the ultimate "tweener" war of the between the pre-industrial Napoleonic War and the Industrial Death of WW1.
The Civil War had so many firsts…
Fun fact I recently learned. The first American submarine attack was ordered by George Washington against a British warship anchored near New York.
2024 Sugar Bowl