Coach Petersen was FIRST and RIGHT
Comments
-
-
The portal sucks. Yeah, it's made SEC-style cheating legal for everyone. Doesn't make it good for the product. My random thoughts on transfers are:
- Each kid should get one transfer during their college eligibility, not to be used until after their first full year at a school. No waiver process, either. Cut and dried.
- One additional transfer is allowed if the coach, who was at the school when the player signed, leaves. The player is not allowed to follow the coach to their new school.
- If the transfer is not due to a coaching change the player has to sit out a year unless they're a grad student. No waivers for immediate eligibility. This year is not counted against the player's eligibility.
- The transfer portal is not opened up until after the completion of spring practices and is open for 2-3 weeks. Allows for the completion of the prior season and full movement of coaches so that the dust is fully settled before kids make big decisions. Coaching change kids get exempted from this window.
- NLI's and NIL need to get paired up in some form or fashion to create a contract for the player and school. College football has turned pro and needs to be regulated the same way.
- Drop the hammer on teams caught tampering. Some programs need to lose a few limbs to scare schools straight.
- Each kid should get one transfer during their college eligibility, not to be used until after their first full year at a school. No waiver process, either. Cut and dried.
-
Non of these ideas work because the schools are independent. Any idea to collectively restrict the contractors/employee "student" athletes bargaining power will lose in court. Almost any restriction from the NCAA or a conference will violate the Sherman Act, which prohibits "contracts, combinations, or conspiracies in restraint of trade or commerce" (First Bannon v NCAA and now strengthened in NCAA v Alston, 2021)
The NFL/MLB/NBA dodge many of the anti trust lawsuits/restrictions because they are really just a single entity and the teams are franchises in conjunction with congressionally passed Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961. (also a bunch of nonsensical specific MLB carve outs about culture and tradition and inconsistently applied restrictions on interstate commerce from 1922).
TLDR: None of these solutions mean anything, they cant stand legally, it will take an act of congress to stop the bleeding; basically its fucked. -
Wouldn't it be in the interests of the universities to re-create the NCAA as the entity under which they serve as franchises? Every other aspect of college athletics have turned into pro sports outside of how the schools are governed.Houhusky said:Non of these ideas work because the schools are independent. Any idea to collectively restrict the contractors/employee "student" athletes bargaining power will lose in court. Almost any restriction from the NCAA or a conference will violate the Sherman Act, which prohibits "contracts, combinations, or conspiracies in restraint of trade or commerce" (First Bannon v NCAA and now strengthened in NCAA v Alston, 2021)
The NFL/MLB/NBA dodge many of the anti trust lawsuits/restrictions because they are really just a single entity and the teams are franchises in conjunction with congressionally passed Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961. (also a bunch of nonsensical specific MLB carve outs about culture and tradition and inconsistently applied restrictions on interstate commerce from 1922).
TLDR: None of these solutions mean anything, they cant stand legally, it will take an act of congress to stop the bleeding; basically its fucked.
If the model is the same five years from now as it is today, I can't see people sticking around and following college athletics in the same numbers as today. We went from a national championship appearance to being destitute overnight. Prior to the past couple weeks, UW had largely avoided the major pitfalls of the portal. Now that I've had a chance to study it up close and personal I'm not going to be around as a fan in a few years if it's not fixed. -
Mother fucking this. The chaos is going to break too many of the fan, UW being a perfect example.BleachedAnusDawg said:
Wouldn't it be in the interests of the universities to re-create the NCAA as the entity under which they serve as franchises? Every other aspect of college athletics have turned into pro sports outside of how the schools are governed.Houhusky said:Non of these ideas work because the schools are independent. Any idea to collectively restrict the contractors/employee "student" athletes bargaining power will lose in court. Almost any restriction from the NCAA or a conference will violate the Sherman Act, which prohibits "contracts, combinations, or conspiracies in restraint of trade or commerce" (First Bannon v NCAA and now strengthened in NCAA v Alston, 2021)
The NFL/MLB/NBA dodge many of the anti trust lawsuits/restrictions because they are really just a single entity and the teams are franchises in conjunction with congressionally passed Sports Broadcasting Act of 1961. (also a bunch of nonsensical specific MLB carve outs about culture and tradition and inconsistently applied restrictions on interstate commerce from 1922).
TLDR: None of these solutions mean anything, they cant stand legally, it will take an act of congress to stop the bleeding; basically its fucked.
If the model is the same five years from now as it is today, I can't see people sticking around and following college athletics in the same numbers as today. We went from a national championship appearance to being destitute overnight. Prior to the past couple weeks, UW had largely avoided the major pitfalls of the portal. Now that I've had a chance to study it up close and personal I'm not going to be around as a fan in a few years if it's not fixed.
And for the record, UW didn't use portal chaos to get to the Natty game in 2023, rather, DeBoer snagged a few key guys, many of whom had hit their expiration dates at other schools. As such, I don't feel like we are hypocrites on this topic. -
College basketball has kind of been ahead of the curve on this and made even worse because players can go pro after one year or just go to the D League and I think they're hemorrhaging fans. I know I for one watch a lot less. It's kind of surviving because of March Madness and brackets/betting. I remember recently checking the box score of the UW/Oregon game and not recognizing like one player and checking each to see almost every single player had played for one and many two schools before. Great path to follow.
-
Obviously, the portal can make for some fun, compelling product and storylines- e.g., Caleb, Penix and Nix helping the Pac brand (too little, too late though).
But, at this point, the NFL does a far better job with managing the product for fan loyalty and engagement.
-
You need transfer fees like euro futbol to deter the constant transfers. Make all the contracts for 4 years, and if you want out the school that wants you needs to negotiate a transfer fee to pay the school you’re leaving.
-
Rick's record breaking salary of $1,000,000 back in 1999 is the equivalent of $1,866,000 in 2023 USD.
I do have to laff at the corch's bitching about all the extra roster management work they have to do as a result of the portal.
Maybe if you fat fucks weren't so fucking greedy, the kids wouldn't have gotten so bitchy about getting a piece of the pie.
I hate the coaches and their bitch ass agents. And I hate kids. -
This isn't changing. Get used to it, or stop watching if you want, but the idea that people are going to walk away from the sport en masse is wishful thinking brought on because we are on the sphincter end of a balls deep ass-raping. The playoff, conference consolidation/relegation paid college players, etc. is going to draw eyes to the sport. Controversy and turmoil it causes will only create more conversation and eyes as people love controversy and tune it to it way more than they do when things are calm.
The fans walking away talk is the same as people that say they are leaving the country based on election results. It doesn't happen.
