Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.

Family owned businesses now will give half to the gov't upon death of the founder?

DerekJohnson
DerekJohnson Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 68,304 Founders Club
edited May 2022 in Tug Tavern
«1

Comments

  • doogie
    doogie Member Posts: 15,072
    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.
  • DerekJohnson
    DerekJohnson Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 68,304 Founders Club
    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
  • TheKobeStopper
    TheKobeStopper Member Posts: 5,959

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
  • DerekJohnson
    DerekJohnson Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 68,304 Founders Club

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    You think all small business owners are worth millions? Then you are brainwashed by Marxists.
  • DerekJohnson
    DerekJohnson Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 68,304 Founders Club

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    And you're implying that if someone built up a business to be worth millions, that it's okay for the government to seize half? Think about what you're saying.
  • BleachedAnusDawg
    BleachedAnusDawg Member Posts: 13,173 Standard Supporter
    @TheKobeStopper

    "You didn't build that."
  • ntxduck
    ntxduck Member Posts: 6,121
    Love to live my life in fear and anger about hypothetical scenarios I make up in my head
  • DerekJohnson
    DerekJohnson Administrator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 68,304 Founders Club
    ntxduck said:

    Love to live my life in fear and anger about hypothetical scenarios I make up in my head

    It's written in the bill.
  • Swaye
    Swaye Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 41,739 Founders Club

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    And you're implying that if someone built up a business to be worth millions, that it's okay for the government to seize half? Think about what you're saying.
    He has though about it. His position is yes, the government is entitled to half of your work, even though you paid taxes on it already during your life once, once you die. To redistribute as they see fit. APAG, and many others like him, are 100% on board with this. So much for the American Dream.
  • greenblood
    greenblood Member Posts: 14,559
    edited August 2021
    It won't stop there. Went to Walmart the other day to by some DEF fluid, and 5pm on a Thursday, there was only one check stand open and everything else was self checkout. I would guess that there were maybe 5 employees total working the floor (counting the two working checkout).

    People are refusing to work until they get a "fair" wage. Unfortunately, for these morons, their definition of a "fair" wage is about 30%-40% more than what the market will pay. Expect to see more and more of these businesses to find ways to do more with less staff, and these people waiting for a "fair" wage will wait themselves into welfare and homelessness. Then with fewer tax payers and more Kobe's sucking up resources, taxes will need to jump into the 50's, or the government will be forced to default, which it won't do.
  • PostGameOrangeSlices
    PostGameOrangeSlices Member Posts: 27,168

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    You think all small business owners are worth millions? Then you are brainwashed by Marxists.
    You needed this comment to know that APAG is a naive malcontent who thinks the government needs to regulate his well being?
  • Tequilla
    Tequilla Member Posts: 20,098

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Even if they are worth millions ... FUCK OFF

  • greenblood
    greenblood Member Posts: 14,559

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
  • TheKobeStopper
    TheKobeStopper Member Posts: 5,959

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
  • TheKobeStopper
    TheKobeStopper Member Posts: 5,959

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    You think all small business owners are worth millions? Then you are brainwashed by Marxists.
    I can’t tell if you’re being intentionally dishonest or you’re just misinformed here but, yes, everyone subject to the estate tax is worth millions.
  • Tequilla
    Tequilla Member Posts: 20,098

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    The one thing you’re missing in this is that a business like this is one that likely is operating on a working line of credit at most but to satisfy the tax burden would either need to leverage either the business with debt or themselves with debt to keep the business afloat

    People like Kobe don’t understand that small family owned businesses (particularly ones that pass from generation to generation) are foundational elements of this country
  • greenblood
    greenblood Member Posts: 14,559
    Tequilla said:

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    The one thing you’re missing in this is that a business like this is one that likely is operating on a working line of credit at most but to satisfy the tax burden would either need to leverage either the business with debt or themselves with debt to keep the business afloat

    People like Kobe don’t understand that small family owned businesses (particularly ones that pass from generation to generation) are foundational elements of this country
    Very good point. Definitely missed that
  • Tequilla
    Tequilla Member Posts: 20,098

    Tequilla said:

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    The one thing you’re missing in this is that a business like this is one that likely is operating on a working line of credit at most but to satisfy the tax burden would either need to leverage either the business with debt or themselves with debt to keep the business afloat

    People like Kobe don’t understand that small family owned businesses (particularly ones that pass from generation to generation) are foundational elements of this country
    Very good point. Definitely missed that
    Your primary point is that Kobe is clueless and supports whatever gives money to those that haven’t earned it
  • whatshouldicareabout
    whatshouldicareabout Member Posts: 12,990
    edited August 2021
    When this finance board was orphaned the first time, did Creepycoug's will pay the govt?
  • TheKobeStopper
    TheKobeStopper Member Posts: 5,959

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    Except the White House has already said it’s going to exempt family owned businesses and farmers who continue to run the business.
  • RaceBannon
    RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 113,759 Founders Club
    Trust the coaches
  • TheKobeStopper
    TheKobeStopper Member Posts: 5,959

    Trust the coaches

    That’s an interesting way to frame “discussing what a proposal proposes”. But I’ve been brainwashed by the marxists, so what do I know.
  • doogie
    doogie Member Posts: 15,072

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    buy/sell agreement funded with Life Insurance.

    Done.

  • RaceBannon
    RaceBannon Member, Moderator, Swaye's Wigwam Posts: 113,759 Founders Club

    Trust the coaches

    That’s an interesting way to frame “discussing what a proposal proposes”. But I’ve been brainwashed by the marxists, so what do I know.
    I make interesting posts
  • greenblood
    greenblood Member Posts: 14,559
    edited August 2021
    doogie said:

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    buy/sell agreement funded with Life Insurance.

    Done.

    How much is a $3.25 million dollar policy? Not very cheap. Especially if the dad has prior or current health issues.

    We have a record percentage of the US population not paying taxes this year. Instead of getting these waste of space shitbags back to work, the government decides to double tax hardworking families. Seems like a bold strategy.
  • GreenRiverGatorz
    GreenRiverGatorz Member Posts: 10,165

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    The Kobes of the world, who want to turn everything into a commune, aside, I think most agree that this is a shitty scenario that we should structure any estate tax law to avoid.

    And as far as I know most succession and estate planning lawyers are able to navigate and avoid this outcome through any number of trusts or special partnership arrangements. How often do we? actually see businesses liquidating in order to meet an estate tax burden?
  • greenblood
    greenblood Member Posts: 14,559

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    The Kobes of the world, who want to turn everything into a commune, aside, I think most agree that this is a shitty scenario that we should structure any estate tax law to avoid.

    And as far as I know most succession and estate planning lawyers are able to navigate and avoid this outcome through any number of trusts or special partnership arrangements. How often do we? actually see businesses liquidating in order to meet an estate tax burden?
    They could just saddle themselves with debt to pay the tax burden as well. Don’t see that as a great option either.
  • GreenRiverGatorz
    GreenRiverGatorz Member Posts: 10,165

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    The Kobes of the world, who want to turn everything into a commune, aside, I think most agree that this is a shitty scenario that we should structure any estate tax law to avoid.

    And as far as I know most succession and estate planning lawyers are able to navigate and avoid this outcome through any number of trusts or special partnership arrangements. How often do we? actually see businesses liquidating in order to meet an estate tax burden?
    They could just saddle themselves with debt to pay the tax burden as well. Don’t see that as a great option either.
    I guess, but the point is that there are a lot of avenues for relief that are utilized on a wide scale, specifically to avoid the scenario you outlined. Avenues that are perfectly legitimate costs of doing business and don't involve debt.

    That's why I'm questioning just how salient your scenario is. It sounds bad, but it's not in the spirit of the estate tax that people advocate for, and in practice I'm not convinced that this is actually occurring at a level we should be concerned about.
  • TheKobeStopper
    TheKobeStopper Member Posts: 5,959

    doogie said:

    This has to be from he Life Insurance Lobby.

    I think it's the ongoing assault on the middle class
    People who own businesses, worth millions, are not middle class.
    Have you ever made your own money, or have you always lived off others?
    Ironic considering the subject of the thread.

    Who cares? That clearly has no value. If it did, you guys wouldn’t be sobbing over exactly how much the children of millionaires should inherit.
    Obviously you failed economics, because you lack little to no understanding of how a business operates. Say Dad passes away from his manufacturing company, and said company is now valued minus liabilities at roughly $6.5 million dollars. If dad founded said company, then you are looking at a capital return of $6.5 million in value. If you tax 50%, that creates a tax bill of $3.25 million. Do you think the business has reserves in place for that kind of bill? So what can the kid's do? Sell the business, or liquidate a large portion of the company's assets (machines, supplies, inventory) to cover the cost. In essence, the government takes a soundly ran family owned business, and turns it into a shell of it's former self. More often enough liquidating the business into bankruptcy or forcing a quick sell to a conglomerate. Which then restricts competitions, and helps create an oligopoly in even more segments of the economy. Great thought process genius. Now I can see why you hate standardized testing so much.
    The Kobes of the world, who want to turn everything into a commune, aside, I think most agree that this is a shitty scenario that we should structure any estate tax law to avoid.

    And as far as I know most succession and estate planning lawyers are able to navigate and avoid this outcome through any number of trusts or special partnership arrangements. How often do we? actually see businesses liquidating in order to meet an estate tax burden?
    I just want people to have healthcare, man.