Welcome to the Hardcore Husky Forums. Folks who are well-known in Cyberland and not that dumb.
Options
Background checks
Sledog
Member Posts: 30,814
in Tug Tavern
Only work if you enter the information in the system! From WSJ.
A federal judge ruled that the U.S. Air Force bears most of the responsibility
for _the 2017 mass shooting_ at a church in Sutherland Springs, Texas, because
it failed to enter the shooter’s criminal history into a federal background
check database used for gun purchases.
The decision Wednesday from U.S. District Judge Xavier Rodriguez of the
Western District of Texas comes in a civil lawsuit brought by survivors and
families of _victims of the massacre_ at the First Baptist Church in
Sutherland Springs, _which left 26 people dead_. The 26-year-old gunman,
former Airman Devin Kelley, killed himself shortly after the attack, the
deadliest mass shooting in Texas history.
In his decision, Judge Rodriguez said the Air Force bore 60% of the
responsibility for the shooting and ordered parties to set a trial plan within
15 days to assess monetary damages for the survivors and victims’ families in
the case.
“The trial conclusively established that no other individual—not even Kelley’s
own parents or partners—knew as much as the United States about the violence
that Devin Kelley had threatened to commit and was capable of committing,” the
judge wrote. “Moreover, the evidence shows that—had the Government done its
job and properly reported Kelley’s information into the background check
system—it is more likely than not that Kelley would have been deterred from
carrying out the Church shooting.”
Kelley had been _convicted in a 2012 general court-martial_ on two counts of
domestic assault on his wife and their child and sentenced to a year in
military jail, which should have barred him from legally buying a gun. But the
Air Force never entered his conviction into the National Instant Criminal
Background Check System, which gun dealers must use to check for criminal
records before selling someone a firearm. As a result, after being thrown out
of the military, Kelley was able to purchase a rifle at a gun store, which he
later used in the Sutherland Springs shooting.
Federal law bars people with felony convictions, which Kelley’s military case
is considered, from owning guns.
“If it wasn’t for these brave families, the government would never have taken
or faced responsibility for their negligence,” said Jamal Alsaffar, a lawyer
for the families.
The Air Force said it wouldn’t comment because the case is ongoing. The
Justice Department, which represented the Air Force in the case, declined to
comment.
Victims’ families alleged in the suit that the Air Force’s failure to enter
_Kelley’s court-martial conviction_ into the NICS database made it liable for
the attack. At the weekslong trial earlier this year, the Air Force admitted
that it failed to enter Kelley’s criminal history into the database but argued
that Kelley was so bent on violence he would have found a way to buy guns
anyway.
“Laws did not stop Devin Kelley,” said Paul Stern, a Justice Department
lawyer, during the trial. “Certainly the NICS would not have stopped him.”
Mr. Stern said that even if Mr. Kelley was barred from legally buying a gun,
he had plenty of other ways of obtaining one in Texas, including buying a
ghost gun kit online, purchasing one at a gun show or forcing his wife to buy
him one. He added that the Air Force couldn’t have foreseen that Kelley’s
history of domestic violence would be precursors to a mass shooting.
The families’ lawyers countered that Kelley preferred to purchase his firearms
through legitimate gun stores and may have been deterred if unable to do so.
They said his well-documented history of violence and legal troubles while
serving in the Air Force made its failure to enter his information into the
FBI database that much more egregious.
Following Kelley’s court-martial in the domestic-assault case, the military
sentenced the then-airman first class to one year in a military jail, a
demotion to the rank of airman basic and a bad-conduct discharge.
“If there’s one thing the Air Force knew about Devin Kelley, it’s that he
liked extreme forms of violence,” said Mr. Alsaffar at trial.
Judge Rodriguez agreed in his ruling, in which he singled out the Air Force
department responsible for investigating crimes committed by airmen and for
entering that information into the background-check database.
Experts on gun laws said the case was particularly notable because it
highlighted serious flaws in the background-check system for gun purchases and
connected them to real-world events more clearly than has been done in a court
in the past.
“This is a landmark decision,” said Eric Ruben, assistant professor at SMU
Dedman School of Law in Dallas.
A federal judge ruled that the U.S. Air Force bears most of the responsibility
for _the 2017 mass shooting_ at a church in Sutherland Springs, Texas, because
it failed to enter the shooter’s criminal history into a federal background
check database used for gun purchases.
The decision Wednesday from U.S. District Judge Xavier Rodriguez of the
Western District of Texas comes in a civil lawsuit brought by survivors and
families of _victims of the massacre_ at the First Baptist Church in
Sutherland Springs, _which left 26 people dead_. The 26-year-old gunman,
former Airman Devin Kelley, killed himself shortly after the attack, the
deadliest mass shooting in Texas history.
In his decision, Judge Rodriguez said the Air Force bore 60% of the
responsibility for the shooting and ordered parties to set a trial plan within
15 days to assess monetary damages for the survivors and victims’ families in
the case.
“The trial conclusively established that no other individual—not even Kelley’s
own parents or partners—knew as much as the United States about the violence
that Devin Kelley had threatened to commit and was capable of committing,” the
judge wrote. “Moreover, the evidence shows that—had the Government done its
job and properly reported Kelley’s information into the background check
system—it is more likely than not that Kelley would have been deterred from
carrying out the Church shooting.”
Kelley had been _convicted in a 2012 general court-martial_ on two counts of
domestic assault on his wife and their child and sentenced to a year in
military jail, which should have barred him from legally buying a gun. But the
Air Force never entered his conviction into the National Instant Criminal
Background Check System, which gun dealers must use to check for criminal
records before selling someone a firearm. As a result, after being thrown out
of the military, Kelley was able to purchase a rifle at a gun store, which he
later used in the Sutherland Springs shooting.
Federal law bars people with felony convictions, which Kelley’s military case
is considered, from owning guns.
“If it wasn’t for these brave families, the government would never have taken
or faced responsibility for their negligence,” said Jamal Alsaffar, a lawyer
for the families.
The Air Force said it wouldn’t comment because the case is ongoing. The
Justice Department, which represented the Air Force in the case, declined to
comment.
Victims’ families alleged in the suit that the Air Force’s failure to enter
_Kelley’s court-martial conviction_ into the NICS database made it liable for
the attack. At the weekslong trial earlier this year, the Air Force admitted
that it failed to enter Kelley’s criminal history into the database but argued
that Kelley was so bent on violence he would have found a way to buy guns
anyway.
“Laws did not stop Devin Kelley,” said Paul Stern, a Justice Department
lawyer, during the trial. “Certainly the NICS would not have stopped him.”
Mr. Stern said that even if Mr. Kelley was barred from legally buying a gun,
he had plenty of other ways of obtaining one in Texas, including buying a
ghost gun kit online, purchasing one at a gun show or forcing his wife to buy
him one. He added that the Air Force couldn’t have foreseen that Kelley’s
history of domestic violence would be precursors to a mass shooting.
The families’ lawyers countered that Kelley preferred to purchase his firearms
through legitimate gun stores and may have been deterred if unable to do so.
They said his well-documented history of violence and legal troubles while
serving in the Air Force made its failure to enter his information into the
FBI database that much more egregious.
Following Kelley’s court-martial in the domestic-assault case, the military
sentenced the then-airman first class to one year in a military jail, a
demotion to the rank of airman basic and a bad-conduct discharge.
“If there’s one thing the Air Force knew about Devin Kelley, it’s that he
liked extreme forms of violence,” said Mr. Alsaffar at trial.
Judge Rodriguez agreed in his ruling, in which he singled out the Air Force
department responsible for investigating crimes committed by airmen and for
entering that information into the background-check database.
Experts on gun laws said the case was particularly notable because it
highlighted serious flaws in the background-check system for gun purchases and
connected them to real-world events more clearly than has been done in a court
in the past.
“This is a landmark decision,” said Eric Ruben, assistant professor at SMU
Dedman School of Law in Dallas.
Comments