Gov. Newsom sued over coronavirus aid plan for California immigrants who lack legal status
Comments
-
See that part.GreenRiverGatorz said:
If you bothered to look at the numbers (lol yeah right) you'd see that illegal immigrants are a net gain for government resources. They contribute more than they take in.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
Now that doesn't mean that CA further sinking into debt to give a hand out to them is sound policy, so don't twist.
That's a problem.
By your logic, the Cartels' meth and heroin dealers are putting money into the economy, too....so, hey, go for it.
-
Cheaper labor —> greater profits —> higher taxesSwaye said:
The problem with this is there are just as many studies that show illegals as a drain, as there are that show them as a net addition. It all depends on the political philosophy of the author it appears.GreenRiverGatorz said:
If you bothered to look at the numbers (lol yeah right) you'd see that illegal immigrants are a net gain for government resources. They contribute more than they take in.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
Now that doesn't mean that CA further sinking into debt to give a hand out to them is sound policy, so don't twist.
edit: I looked at this via the googlebots for 10 minutes, so if there exists a true fair impartial (our government is not fair nor impartial) study bu a neutral party I'd be interested in seeing their conclusions. -
And you'd be talking out your ass as usual. This is money coming from the Federal government. You being a dumbfuck think that because they pay a state sales tax that somehow covers money coming from Federal taxes.HustlinOwl said:
California has a 7.25% sales tax so I would say almost all of them pay into the system. Once again Alt lies.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
And I'd say some of that money goes into building a road or paying a government official who pays some of that in Federal taxes so fuck off.SFGbob said:
And I'd say not of dime of those taxes cover money coming from the Federal government. Nice work dumbfuck.HustlinOwl said:
California has a 7.25% sales tax so I would say almost all of them pay into the system. Once again Alt lies.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
-
Eh but by that measure the whole point of the left claiming this (which is empathy and compassion) is invalid because they don't care if it screws over citizensGrundleStiltzkin said:
Cheaper labor —> greater profits —> higher taxesSwaye said:
The problem with this is there are just as many studies that show illegals as a drain, as there are that show them as a net addition. It all depends on the political philosophy of the author it appears.GreenRiverGatorz said:
If you bothered to look at the numbers (lol yeah right) you'd see that illegal immigrants are a net gain for government resources. They contribute more than they take in.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
Now that doesn't mean that CA further sinking into debt to give a hand out to them is sound policy, so don't twist.
edit: I looked at this via the googlebots for 10 minutes, so if there exists a true fair impartial (our government is not fair nor impartial) study bu a neutral party I'd be interested in seeing their conclusions. -
You're correct, that was an oversight on my part. While immigrants as a whole are a net fiscal benefit, illegal immigrants are undoubtedly a drain. That was a moment of fucktardedness for me to conflate the two. Must have been all that chloroquine I've been chugging.PurpleThrobber said:
See that part.GreenRiverGatorz said:
If you bothered to look at the numbers (lol yeah right) you'd see that illegal immigrants are a net gain for government resources. They contribute more than they take in.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
Now that doesn't mean that CA further sinking into debt to give a hand out to them is sound policy, so don't twist.
That's a problem.
By your logic, the Cartels' meth and heroin dealers are putting money into the economy, too....so, hey, go for it.
A mea culpa to @Bendintheriver (that hurts to type) -
Tug Tavern: Peace in Our TimGreenRiverGatorz said:
You're correct, that was an oversight on my part. While immigrants as a whole are a net fiscal benefit, illegal immigrants are undoubtedly a drain. That was a moment of fucktardedness for me to conflate the two. Must have been all that chloroquine I've been chugging.PurpleThrobber said:
See that part.GreenRiverGatorz said:
If you bothered to look at the numbers (lol yeah right) you'd see that illegal immigrants are a net gain for government resources. They contribute more than they take in.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
Now that doesn't mean that CA further sinking into debt to give a hand out to them is sound policy, so don't twist.
That's a problem.
By your logic, the Cartels' meth and heroin dealers are putting money into the economy, too....so, hey, go for it.
A mea culpa to @Bendintheriver (that hurts to type) -
Years ago, long before Kali went sanctuary, the cost of illegals to the state of Kali was 5 billion a year. It's probably double that now.GreenRiverGatorz said:
If you bothered to look at the numbers (lol yeah right) you'd see that illegal immigrants are a net gain for government resources. They contribute more than they take in.Bendintheriver said:A governor of a state is going to take 75 million tax dollars and spend it on foreigners. A majority who pay nothing into the system and as a group are already a huge drain on the system. Californians have a right to be pissed.
Now that doesn't mean that CA further sinking into debt to give a hand out to them is sound policy, so don't twist.
They suck the whole system dry. That's a fact Jack!
